Creamy Chicken and Mushroom Pie

Golden puff lid over a white-wine chicken filling, pub standard.

Prep Time35 mins
Cook Time30 mins
Total Time1 hr 5 mins
YieldServes 5 to 6
Creamy Chicken and Mushroom Pie
Save to Pinterest
🛒 Our baking picks

Tools for foolproof bakes

Weighing beats scooping every time. These inexpensive tools make every recipe more reliable.

Digital kitchen scale Digital kitchen scale Weigh to the gram, the single most accurate way to bake. Available at Amazon Check price → Measuring cups & spoons Measuring cups & spoons A solid stainless set for when a recipe calls for cups. Available at Amazon Check price → Glass measuring jug Glass measuring jug Read millilitres and cups at a glance for liquids. Available at Amazon Check price →

As an Amazon Associate, GramCups earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Before You Start

The pub pie, done honestly: browned thighs and mushrooms in a creamy white wine sauce under shop puff pastry, which no one should apologise for. A top-crust-only pie means no soggy bottom is even possible, and the filling cooling before the lid goes on is the one rule that keeps the pastry crisp.

Instructions

  1. 1

    Brown the chicken chunks in half the butter in a wide pan and set aside. Brown the mushrooms hard in the same pan until their water is gone and they squeak, and set aside too.

  2. 2

    Soften the leek in the rest of the butter, add the garlic, then stir in the flour for a minute.

  3. 3

    Add the wine, letting it bubble out, then the stock gradually, stirring to a smooth sauce. Stir in the cream, mustard and thyme.

  4. 4

    Return the chicken and mushrooms, simmer 5 minutes, season well, and cool the filling at least 20 minutes. Hot filling melts pastry from below before the oven can cook it from above.

  5. 5

    Heat the oven to 200°C / 400°F. Tip the filling into a pie dish, lay the pastry over, trim, crimp to the rim, and cut two vents. Decorate with trimmings if you are that person, glaze with egg either way.

  6. 6

    Bake 25 to 30 minutes until the lid is tall, glossy and deep gold. Rest 5 minutes before breaking the crust.

💡 Baker's tips

  • Cool the filling before lidding, always. It is the entire difference between shatter-crisp pastry and a sad damp ceiling.
  • Brown the mushrooms properly, alone, until dry. Pale wet mushrooms water the sauce down and taste of nothing.

🔀 Make it your own

  • A handful of frozen peas or chopped tarragon into the sauce with the cream.
  • Swap chicken for leftover roast turkey, the correct fate of a Boxing Day fridge.

📦 Storing & freezing

Fridge for 2 days, reheating at 180°C until piping (the microwave rubberises pastry). The filling alone freezes 3 months: thaw, top with fresh pastry, and bake.

❓ Frequently asked

How do you keep a pie lid from going soggy?

Cool the filling before the pastry goes on, cut proper vents, and bake hot at 200°C. A top-crust pie with those three habits stays crisp to the last slice.

Can I use shop-bought puff pastry?

Yes, without shame: laminating pastry at home is a weekend project, not a Tuesday one. Buy all-butter puff and everyone wins. Chefs do the same.

Baking in a different unit? Use the cups ↔ grams converter or the recipe scaler to halve or double this recipe.

More to bake

Cheesy Baked Ziti Savoury Mains Cheesy Baked Ziti Saucy pasta baked under a blanket of melted mozzarella. Creamy Baked Mac and Cheese Savoury Mains Creamy Baked Mac and Cheese A proper roux-based cheese sauce, baked with a crunchy top. One-Pan Chicken and Vegetable Traybake Savoury Mains One-Pan Chicken and Vegetable Traybake Chicken thighs roasted with potatoes and peppers on one tray.
Play GramCups Café 🎮